The Eye That Never Sleeps: From Orwell to Reality TV
- Marcelo Serafim
- 12 hours ago
- 5 min read
The reality television phenomenon Big Brother takes its name directly from George Orwell’s dystopian masterpiece, 1984. In the novel, Big Brother is the enigmatic, omnipresent leader of Oceania, a totalitarian state where every citizen is under constant surveillance. The phrase "Big Brother is Watching You" serves as a chilling reminder that privacy is non-existent and dissent is fatal. While the TV show is a source of entertainment rather than political terror, the shared nomenclature highlights a fascination with the loss of the private sphere.
Orwell’s Big Brother represents the ultimate form of panopticism—the idea that people will behave if they believe they are being watched at all times. In the book, "telescreens" in every home broadcast propaganda while simultaneously filming the occupants. The television show replicates this environment by placing "housemates" in a custom-built home rigged with cameras and microphones. The fundamental difference, of course, is that the contestants volunteer for this scrutiny, trading their privacy for a shot at fame and a cash prize.
The link between the two lies in the psychological impact of constant observation. In 1984, the protagonist, Winston Smith, must carefully mask his facial expressions to avoid being accused of "facecrime." Similarly, contestants on the reality show are hyper-aware of their public image. They often perform for the cameras, creating a tension between their "authentic" selves and the personas they project to the audience. This "performance of the self" is a direct descendant of the survival tactics used by Orwell’s characters.
In the novel, Big Brother’s power is maintained through the manipulation of information and language. The Party uses "Newspeak" to limit the range of thought. While the reality show doesn't control language to that extreme, the production team (the "Producers") acts as a god-like entity. They choose which clips to air, how to edit conversations, and which narratives to push. Much like the Ministry of Truth, the editors have the power to rewrite the "truth" of what happened in the house to suit a more dramatic storyline.
The concept of the "Diary Room" in the show serves as a modern-day confessional, mirroring the interrogations in 1984. In the book, the state wants to own the thoughts of its citizens; in the show, the audience craves the "inner truth" of the contestants. The Diary Room is the only place where housemates can speak directly to the viewers, yet even there, they are talking to a disembodied voice—a literal "Big Brother" who guides their narrative through pointed questioning.
Social isolation is another bridge between the fiction and the reality. Winston Smith feels utterly alone in a crowd because he cannot trust anyone. In the Big Brother house, contestants are stripped of contact with the outside world—no phones, no internet, and no news. This isolation forces them to form alliances that are often built on a foundation of paranoia and strategic necessity, mirroring the fragile and treacherous social bonds found within the Party.
The "Two Minutes Hate" in Orwell’s world is a daily ritual where citizens vent their rage at "enemies of the state." Modern reality TV often mirrors this through social media discourse. When a "villain" emerges on the show, the public often engages in a digital version of the Two Minutes Hate, fueled by edited footage. The spectacle of public shaming remains a powerful tool for social control, whether it's in a fictional dictatorship or a trending hashtag.
Furthermore, the show explores the "gamification" of surveillance. In 1984, surveillance is a tool for oppression; in Big Brother, it is a tool for competition. The audience assumes the role of the "Thought Police," voting to evict those who do not conform to their expectations or who play the game poorly. We, the viewers, become complicit in the surveillance state, finding pleasure in the very thing Orwell warned would be our downfall.
The evolution of the show since its debut in 1999 reflects our changing attitudes toward privacy. When the book was written in 1948, the idea of being watched 24/7 was a nightmare. Today, with the rise of social media and "vlogging," many people actively seek the gaze of the public. The Big Brother house is no longer a scary outlier; it is a concentrated version of our everyday lives where we are both the watched and the watchers.
Ultimately, the link between the show and the book serves as a cultural Rorschach test. It asks us to consider the price of our attention and the value of our solitude. While the show ends with a winner and a party, Orwell’s story ends with a soul crushed by the state. The fact that we use the name of a fictional tyrant for a prime-time entertainment program suggests that we have either conquered our fear of surveillance or, more likely, we have simply learned to love Big Brother.
Comprehension Questions
How does the concept of "panopticism" apply to both the book 1984 and the TV show?
What is the primary difference between why people are watched in the novel versus the reality show?
In what way do the show's producers act like the "Ministry of Truth"?
How does the "Diary Room" function as a psychological tool in the show?
Why does the article suggest that the "Two Minutes Hate" still exists in modern society?
Vocabulary: 10 Difficult Words
Omnipresent: Present everywhere at the same time.
Totalitarian: Relating to a system of government that is centralized and dictatorial and requires complete subservience to the state.
Panopticism: A social theory named after a circular prison design where all inmates can be observed by a single watchman without knowing they are being watched.
Dissent: The expression or holding of opinions at variance with those previously, commonly, or officially held.
Nomenclature: A system of names or terms used in a particular branch of knowledge or art.
Hyper-aware: Extremely or excessively conscious of something.
Disembodied: Separated from or existing without a body.
Complicit: Involved with others in an illegal activity or wrongdoing.
Gamification: The application of typical elements of game playing (e.g., point scoring, competition) to other areas of activity.
Rorschach test: A psychological test in which subjects' perceptions of inkblots are recorded and then analyzed; used here to mean something that is interpreted in different ways depending on the person.
Phrasal Verb
To Act Out
Meaning: To perform or express one's feelings through outward behavior, often to get attention.
Example: "Some contestants in the Big Brother house start to act out when they realize the cameras haven't focused on them for a while."
American Idiom
Under the Microscope
Meaning: To be under very close scrutiny or examination.
Example: "Once you enter the Big Brother house, your entire personal history and every word you speak is under the microscope."
English Grammar Tip: The Passive Voice
In the text, the passive voice is used to emphasize the action or the person being acted upon, rather than the person doing the action. This is common when discussing surveillance because the "watcher" is often hidden.
Structure: [Object] + [Form of "to be"] + [Past Participle]
Example from text: "Every citizen is observed." (Emphasis is on the citizen's lack of privacy).
Active vs. Passive: * Active: The producers film the housemates.
Passive: The housemates are filmed by the producers.
Listening
Homework Proposal
The Surveillance Journal: For the next 24 hours, keep a log of every time you are "watched" by technology (CCTV, app tracking, cookies on websites, or social media tags). At the end of the day, write a one-page reflection on whether knowing you were being tracked changed your behavior. Would you act differently if your "log" was being broadcast to millions of people?
Would you like me to help you draft a response to one of those comprehension questions or perhaps create a quiz based on the vocabulary?
Comments